Stathers graduated from Chopticon High School in Morganza, Maryland, in 2016. She played four years as the goalkeeper on the women's soccer team. She served as team captain for two seasons and won coaches awards in 2013 and 2015. Stathers also played ice hockey in Annapolis for the U19 youth girl's hockey team. She played from 2013-15 until an injury forced her to retire from playing.
Stathers assisted in coaching the girl's soccer junior varsity team her senior year at Chopticon after suffering her injury. She also coached at summer camps for goalkeepers for two summers after high school.
Stathers graduated from Salisbury University in Salisbury, Maryland, in 2022 with a degree in exercise science. She is currently studying at CSM to obtain a degree as a physical therapy assistant.
Stathers is a St. Mary's County resident. She has a golden retriever named Nala and a cat named Lily.